Arsenic and Old Lace

Want to have some fun? Want to roll in the aisles with laughter? Stage Right Players may have the answer for you at the Crighton Theater with their uproarious current production of Joseph Kesselring’s comedy romp, Arsenic and Old Lace.Now, mind you, I said “may have the answer.” You must first bring with you a certain set of audience skills, foremost among them the ability to suspend your disbelief of the frantically nutty and highly improbable plot. If you can pass that test, a great deal of fun lies in store for you, and this is a cast that can really deliver the laughs in this classic comedy under the skillful direction of Brenda Storseth.

Mortimer Brewster (Michael Blake Oldham) is a sometimes-reluctant theater critic in love with the very lovely Elaine Harper (Cassandra Roschen), who happens to be the daughter of the pleasantly pious Reverend Dr. Harper (Greg Kelly). The couple’s engagement to be married brings with it a new supply of laughs, and Roschen adds a pleasant twist of exasperation as perhaps the only really sane character in the play. The action plays out in the beautiful Victorian home of Mortimer’s two amusingly eccentric aunts, Abby (Leona Hoegsberg) and Martha (Carolyn Corsano Wong). Mr. Oldham, meanwhile, has possibly the greatest acting challenge conveying Mortimer’s reactions as he begins to discover that his outwardly sweet aunties are, in fact, mass murderers. The charming Victorian set (scenic designers, Ms. Storseth, Dennis O’Connor & Katt Gilcrease) and the equally charming period costumes combine to give this production the polished glow (lighting designs by Roger Ormiston).

Now, on to the thoroughly far-fetched fun that awaits you. Mortimer’s Aunts are elegant, dignified, -- and screwy! They have developed a certain odd kind of Christian charity that involves occasionally serving the unsuspecting an arsenic-spiked elderberry wine thinking it will bring final peace to any lonely old men without families who happen to drop in to rent rooms in the house. Sound crazy? You betcha, but somehow the premise begins to catch fire in assorted hilarious ways.

There are dry patches when the comedy drops off a bit, but the comic cause is greatly advanced by the arrival of Mortimer’s long-lost and very sinister brother, Jonathan Brewster (a threatening performance from Mr. Gilcrease), and his crazy partner in crime, Dr. Einstein (Dennis O’Connor). Mr. O’Connor’s performance is a wonderful reminder why the actor was greatly missed during the several years destiny took him far away from Conroe. Now he is back and playing a dangerous game, but he is winning hands down. He clearly based his characterization on that of the late Peter Lorre who hilariously played the Dr. Einstein role in the classic film version of this dark comedy that starred Cary Grant as Mortimer. Trying to capture the mannerisms of another well-known actor can be tricky at best, but O’Connor accomplishes this task with such uproarious and consummate skill, I found myself gasping for breath amid my roars of laughter. He must be channeling the spirit of Mr. Lorre.